A Feast for Crows Discussion [Book 4] *Formerly the "book" thread

Discussion in 'Game of Thrones (ASOIAF)' started by cheddarisbetter, May 24, 2010.

  1. Dr. Driskel

    Dr. Driskel New Member

    anywhere all this Pate stuff is already explained? I didn't pick up who the alchemist stuff.
     
  2. Celemo

    Celemo Meatball's Dad
    Donor
    Michigan WolverinesPortland Trail BlazersWu-tangOregon State Beavers alt

    per wiki

    Pate was a novice studying to become a maester at the Citadel in Oldtown. He was also a patron of the Quill and Tankard inn, and was in love with the innkeeper's daughter, Rosey. With his studies not proceeding well, Pate agreed to steal a key that would open every door in the Citadel for a man known as 'the alchemist' in return for money. Having performed this service, Pate was then killed by the alchemist, who expressed regret for the necessity. As he died, Pate saw the man take on his own appearance. The imposter then replaced him in the Citadel. Later, the 'fake Pate' was revealed to be in the service of Archmaester Marwyn and an associate of Alleras the Sphinx, although it is unknown if they knew of his true identity.
     
  3. Cawgs or Gie!

    Cawgs or Gie! The next Jordy Nelson, obviously.
    Donor
    Georgia BulldogsAtlanta BravesAtlanta FalconsAtlanta UnitedLiverpool

    Anyone heard the theory regarding the identity of alleras the sphinx?
     
  4. BayouMafia

    BayouMafia that slumdog millionaire Bollywood flow
    Staff Donor
    FulhamLSU TigersNew Orleans SaintsTexas Rangers

    yes
     
  5. football501

    football501 I once ate a Twix with the wrapper on it
    TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersKansas City RoyalsEvertonAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer Team

    No, where would I find it?
     
  6. Cawgs or Gie!

    Cawgs or Gie! The next Jordy Nelson, obviously.
    Donor
    Georgia BulldogsAtlanta BravesAtlanta FalconsAtlanta UnitedLiverpool

    Do you buy it?

    Westers.org
    the theory is that alleras is a she in disguise and is one of the sand snakes of dorne named sarella (anagram for alleras)
     
  7. Celemo

    Celemo Meatball's Dad
    Donor
    Michigan WolverinesPortland Trail BlazersWu-tangOregon State Beavers alt

    would be bad ass if true
     
  8. BayouMafia

    BayouMafia that slumdog millionaire Bollywood flow
    Staff Donor
    FulhamLSU TigersNew Orleans SaintsTexas Rangers

    Yep I think that's exactly what the case is
     
    Cawgs or Gie! likes this.
  9. Eamudo229

    Eamudo229 Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Florida GatorsJacksonville Jaguars

    It has to be the case, it is almost too obvious though with Alleras being Sarella backwards. I just finished reading AFFC so with all the details fresh in my head it matches up so perfectly (a dornish father, a summer island trader for a mother, proficient with some weapon like all of the ther sand snakes mentioned) it has to be her disguised as a man. I did totally miss it the first time through however.
     
    Cawgs or Gie! likes this.
  10. NCHusker88

    NCHusker88 We named our yam Pam. It rhymed.
    Donor TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersChicago CubsDenver NuggetsKansas City ChiefsAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer TeamUSA BasketballBig 8 ConferenceBig Ten ConferenceNebraska Cornhuskers alt

    haven't read any of the thread but I've really been struggling to consistently read this one. Roughly half way through

    no Tyrion, no Bran, hardly any night's watch, no Daenerys, barely any Arya, etc. The only storylines that have really been interesting to me at all have been Brienne's and the Iron Islands. Cersei is a bitch, Jamie mostly does nothing. Hoping this shit picks up soon but will truck through it regardless.
     
  11. Celemo

    Celemo Meatball's Dad
    Donor
    Michigan WolverinesPortland Trail BlazersWu-tangOregon State Beavers alt

    You'll like the end of book 4. Book 5 is the tits
     
    Cronk likes this.
  12. NCHusker88

    NCHusker88 We named our yam Pam. It rhymed.
    Donor TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersChicago CubsDenver NuggetsKansas City ChiefsAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer TeamUSA BasketballBig 8 ConferenceBig Ten ConferenceNebraska Cornhuskers alt

    awesome. will knock a few chapters out this afternoon.
     
  13. Guns

    Guns yeah, but what about antifa?
    Donor

    can you refresh my memory on the Gravedigger? what was this about, I know the hound is missing. I remember the monk guy on the island saying he buried him, not buying it

    nvm, read some tower of the hand, got it now.
     
  14. Celemo

    Celemo Meatball's Dad
    Donor
    Michigan WolverinesPortland Trail BlazersWu-tangOregon State Beavers alt

    if memory serves...the Elder brother suggested that "The Hound" was a facet of Clegane's psyche and that is what died and what's left of Sandor joined the Quiet Isle Monks.
     
  15. LT8

    LT8 Well-Known Member

    This. And the gravedigger being extremely large, a novice, walked with a limp, good with the dogs, etc
     
  16. NCHusker88

    NCHusker88 We named our yam Pam. It rhymed.
    Donor TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersChicago CubsDenver NuggetsKansas City ChiefsAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer TeamUSA BasketballBig 8 ConferenceBig Ten ConferenceNebraska Cornhuskers alt

    Okay this shit is really starting to get good.

    Brienne just got attacked at the crossroads by Biter, Jaime just freed Edmure, and Sam knows about Daenrys
     
  17. OTM

    OTM Apathy chic: you can't be hurt if you don't care.
    Donor
    Nebraska CornhuskersSan Francisco 49'ersSt. Louis Blues

    Book picks it up a notch at the end.
     
  18. Lawnole23

    Lawnole23 Well-Known Member
    Donor TMB OG
    Florida State SeminolesTampa Bay RaysTampa Bay BuccaneersTampa Bay Lightning

    I'm probably 8 or so chapters into ADWD and I keep getting deja vu. Because the beginning of it is the same time as a AFFC you keep reading about things you already know about from Crows. So Sam recalls having some conversation with Jon before he left and then in Dragons you see the actual conversation happen. I keep thinking haven't I already read this?
     
  19. NCHusker88

    NCHusker88 We named our yam Pam. It rhymed.
    Donor TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersChicago CubsDenver NuggetsKansas City ChiefsAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer TeamUSA BasketballBig 8 ConferenceBig Ten ConferenceNebraska Cornhuskers alt

    Yeah I finished it last night then promptly went to Target and bought DwD. I'm about 80 pages in
     
  20. NCHusker88

    NCHusker88 We named our yam Pam. It rhymed.
    Donor TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersChicago CubsDenver NuggetsKansas City ChiefsAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer TeamUSA BasketballBig 8 ConferenceBig Ten ConferenceNebraska Cornhuskers alt

    in hindsight I really enjoyed the paranoia of Cersei causing her to make dozens of terrible decisions.

    Fuck that bitch

    edit: also loved Jaime telling her to fuck off
     
    cconn likes this.
  21. The Blackfish

    The Blackfish The Fish in Black
    Staff Donor TMB OG
    Alabama Crimson TideIndianapolis Colts

    Come back when you finish that chapter
     
  22. Lawnole23

    Lawnole23 Well-Known Member
    Donor TMB OG
    Florida State SeminolesTampa Bay RaysTampa Bay BuccaneersTampa Bay Lightning

    I have finished it the chapter. Nevermind I realized I'm still in the middle of the chapter. We shall discuss tomorrow.
     
  23. Lawnole23

    Lawnole23 Well-Known Member
    Donor TMB OG
    Florida State SeminolesTampa Bay RaysTampa Bay BuccaneersTampa Bay Lightning

    Fuck yea Jon Snow finished that chapter.
     
    NCHusker88 likes this.
  24. NCHusker88

    NCHusker88 We named our yam Pam. It rhymed.
    Donor TMB OG
    Nebraska CornhuskersChicago CubsDenver NuggetsKansas City ChiefsAvengersUnited States Men's National Soccer TeamUSA BasketballBig 8 ConferenceBig Ten ConferenceNebraska Cornhuskers alt

    I finished that chapter this morning. Snow is turning into a fucking boss
     
  25. Lawnole23

    Lawnole23 Well-Known Member
    Donor TMB OG
    Florida State SeminolesTampa Bay RaysTampa Bay BuccaneersTampa Bay Lightning

    If I know Martin like I think I do though that means bad things on the horizon for Jon Snow I'm assuming. Martin is the kind of asshole that would have Jon Snow somehow become King of Westeros and then have a space ship fly down and zap him with a laser and fly off. The end.
     
    Bruns and Celemo like this.
  26. colonelrascals

    colonelrascals Mayonnaise-colored Benz, I push miracle whips
    Donor
    Texas Tech Red RaidersHouston AstrosHouston RocketsTennisTottenham HotspurTexas Tech Red Raiders alt

    I just finished chapter 6 (the first sam chapter), and I dont know why everyone is hating on book I am really enjoying it.
     
  27. OTM

    OTM Apathy chic: you can't be hurt if you don't care.
    Donor
    Nebraska CornhuskersSan Francisco 49'ersSt. Louis Blues

    It's just a change of pace from the other three, and the the POV's are centered on newer or unpopular characters. I really did enjoy the last quarter of the book, though.
     
  28. colonelrascals

    colonelrascals Mayonnaise-colored Benz, I push miracle whips
    Donor
    Texas Tech Red RaidersHouston AstrosHouston RocketsTennisTottenham HotspurTexas Tech Red Raiders alt

    It is a change of pace, but I like where everything is going. I guess it just is the worst by default:idk:
     
  29. OTM

    OTM Apathy chic: you can't be hurt if you don't care.
    Donor
    Nebraska CornhuskersSan Francisco 49'ersSt. Louis Blues

    Pretty much, still an excellent book on its own, just not as good as the others in my humblest.
     
  30. colonelrascals

    colonelrascals Mayonnaise-colored Benz, I push miracle whips
    Donor
    Texas Tech Red RaidersHouston AstrosHouston RocketsTennisTottenham HotspurTexas Tech Red Raiders alt

  31. Manny

    Manny I love lamp.

    I get to finally read this bitch.
     
  32. zeberdee

    zeberdee read it? I own it. but no, I have not read it
    Donor TMB OG
    Penn State Nittany LionsPhiladelphia PhilliesPhiladelphia 76'ersPhiladelphia EaglesPhiladelphia FlyersArsenalPhiladelphia UnionUnited States Men's National Soccer Team

    the Victarion chapter titled The Reaver in this book might be the most badass chapter in all the books.
     
    War Taint and Larry Sura like this.
  33. Duane Coleman

    Duane Coleman Well-Known Member
    Donor

    Just finished AFFC and have to agree the first 3/4ths of the book was slow compared to ASOS but the last hundred or so pages really finished strong.
     
  34. UA412

    UA412 Well-Known Member
    Staff TMB OG
    Arizona Wildcats

    Didn't think this was up for debate.
    <3 Victarion
    You don't have the big three Dany, Tyrion, and Jon. Also you have a bunch of just awful characters and it's really only telling half the story. I just don't think the whole split was the best idea but I understand why he did it. You do have several good stories in it [my favorite being Arya and the kingsmoot storyline]. The book is good but it's a step below book 5 and book 1 so it's the worst book to me. Book 5 and 1 are very good though so it's not really a negative.

    Numbers are based on my rankings of the book
    3

    2
    1/5
    4
     
  35. Clubber Lang

    Clubber Lang High Potentate
    Donor

    into Chapter 12 now of AFFC now... book's getting better but the Iron Island chapters are about as boring as Silas Marner. Still hate that book from high school.
     
  36. Corky Bucek

    Corky Bucek Knock on wood if you are with me
    Staff Donor TMB OG
    Auburn TigersLos Angeles LakersLos Angeles RamsAnaheim DucksManchester United

    About 120 pages in, no clue on chapter number but it was Tywin's funeral. Jesus I hate her, such a bitch who thinks everybody is out to get her (which is probably true).
     
  37. Lloyd Xmas

    Lloyd Xmas Don't you go dyin' on me
    Donor

    Just finished AFFC, I need to reread the sam chapter, but is Alleras the kid that said he was Pate? And is this Pate the same one that was the whipping boy? If that's not Alleras, can someone explain the theory of who he his?
     
  38. Duane Coleman

    Duane Coleman Well-Known Member
    Donor

    A man can have many faces
     
    Jaqen H'ghar likes this.
  39. Irush

    Irush Fairwell Solenya
    Donor TMB OG

    this

    also
    Alleras is Sarella Sand, she's mentioned in an Arianne chapter by Doran as "off playing her game"
     
  40. Voodoo

    Voodoo Fan of: Notre Dame
    Donor
    Notre Dame Fighting IrishTottenham HotspurSan Francisco Giants

    The real Pate is dead. He was killed by someone with a hook nose and black curly hair who he called the alchemist.
     
  41. Jaqen H'ghar

    Jaqen H'ghar Valar Morghulis

    Straight up murked that fool, a man did.
     
  42. Fuzzy Zoeller

    Fuzzy Zoeller College football > NFL

    I'm 140 pages in to this book and will read Cersei II tonight. I hope this book doesn't do what ASOS did and make me like another Lannister. I want to continue hating this bitch.
     
  43. Lloyd Xmas

    Lloyd Xmas Don't you go dyin' on me
    Donor

    lol
     
    football501 likes this.
  44. The Blackfish

    The Blackfish The Fish in Black
    Staff Donor TMB OG
    Alabama Crimson TideIndianapolis Colts

    lol
     
    football501 likes this.
  45. Fuzzy Zoeller

    Fuzzy Zoeller College football > NFL

    I'm about 400 pages into this book and have realized this will be the most difficult book by far to adapt to TV. Will be interesting to see all the showfags rage.
     
  46. The Blackfish

    The Blackfish The Fish in Black
    Staff Donor TMB OG
    Alabama Crimson TideIndianapolis Colts

    They will have do it chronologically imo which will mix parts of AFFC and ADWD
     
    Keef likes this.
  47. Fuzzy Zoeller

    Fuzzy Zoeller College football > NFL

    That makes sense. Otherwise it would almost be like starting a brand new series with all this focus on Dorne and the Iron Islands.
     
  48. Lloyd Xmas

    Lloyd Xmas Don't you go dyin' on me
    Donor

    Wonder if they'll leave a lot of stuff out to make it easier to follow if they mix ADWD and AFFC. Having so many characters will be tough for a tv viewer to follow.
     
  49. The Blackfish

    The Blackfish The Fish in Black
    Staff Donor TMB OG
    Alabama Crimson TideIndianapolis Colts

    If they mix them they will do it over 2-3 seasons imo
     
  50. Fuzzy Zoeller

    Fuzzy Zoeller College football > NFL

    I planned on reading 3 chapters last night until I got stuck on a 25-page Brienne chapter and fell asleep while reading it, so needless to say I only got through one. Woke up pissed off that GRRM put me through that.