New Bourbon Thread: The Main Bourbon Club

Discussion in 'The Mainboard' started by tjsblue, Dec 2, 2019.

  1. DistantFactor

    DistantFactor Sesquipedalian
    Donor
    Oregon DucksPortland Trail Blazers

    They better not kill my Pikesville rye, one of my favorite bottles I can easily find.
     
    Tangman, Lipp and Bo Pelinis like this.
  2. gilstein21

    gilstein21 Tight Rip 26 Seal Right
    Washington State CougarsAuburn TigersSt. Louis CardinalsGreen Bay PackersWyoming Cowboys

    Exactly, but if it becomes relabeled EC rye as store picks and barrel proofs, it wont be a total loss.
     
  3. DistantFactor

    DistantFactor Sesquipedalian
    Donor
    Oregon DucksPortland Trail Blazers

    I can already buy that whenever I want so that doesn’t help me. Keep in mind the world needs to revolve around me.
     
  4. gilstein21

    gilstein21 Tight Rip 26 Seal Right
    Washington State CougarsAuburn TigersSt. Louis CardinalsGreen Bay PackersWyoming Cowboys

    Ec rye barrel proof doesn’t exist yet as far as I know, and I’ve never heard of an ec rye store pick.
     
    DistantFactor likes this.
  5. pratyk

    pratyk Arsenal FC, Rutgers Scarlet Knights
    Rutgers Scarlet KnightsArsenal

    I'm a sucker for port so if no one else is calling dibs, I'd love to get the samples. That's only if it's not a pain in the ass to go out of your way to ship them.
     
    kentucky_dawg and pperc like this.
  6. Frankie Carbone

    Frankie Carbone eh che se dice
    Florida State SeminolesNew York YankeesNew York KnicksTampa Bay BuccaneersOrlando CityLazio

    That’s what I was wondering. Did anyone get any of the port finish that didn’t deliver?
     
  7. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    I’m going to do you a favor and tell you to pass. They were not good.
     
    sem, pperc, g8r and 2 others like this.
  8. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    Hang on putting on my cunty hat:

    it wasn’t so much that they were bitter or over Oaked, they tasted young, and abrasive. Two of the samples left me with the taste of what nail polish remover smells like on my tongue.

    Neither of the first two had any real strong character to them. The nose gave away that they were younger barrels imo, because there wasn’t much to them other than the assertive harsh notes you catch often on young and inconsistent bourbon. Even proofing each sample down they were still bad. None of the deep red fruit notes you’d expect from a port finish. The barrel numbers on the first two were like 9 numbers apart, so it would stand to reason that they came from the same area of the shit stable.

    The third sample literally had almost no nose on it. A little soft hint of honey/brown sugar but proofing that shit down it’d smell like Evian.

    You could catch a little bit of the fruitiness on the back end of the third one it was an ok pour but nothing I would go back to or be interested in revisiting. The mouth feel on all three was non existent, didn’t leave you with any of that almost oily viscosity that makes drinking something like EHT BP so nice because it sits with you for so long after you drink it. The finish was almost non existent other than the slight hit of fruit, but even that was pretty fucking fleeting. It was much smoother than the other two and didn’t have the harshness the first two did. It was fine, but at 125 proof I was almost shocked by how little flavor it had. I dropped some water in it a little as well and it just got more boring, was it drinkable? Yes. Would I recommend others buy it especially if it was proofed down? No, it was a pass for me.
     
  9. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    The first two barrels were legitimately offensive to my taste buds
     
  10. pratyk

    pratyk Arsenal FC, Rutgers Scarlet Knights
    Rutgers Scarlet KnightsArsenal

    I suppose I should just revisit my MND bottle.
     
    g8r likes this.
  11. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    A much better call
     
  12. Frankie Carbone

    Frankie Carbone eh che se dice
    Florida State SeminolesNew York YankeesNew York KnicksTampa Bay BuccaneersOrlando CityLazio

    This is what I pay for
     
    construxboy likes this.
  13. BrickTamland

    BrickTamland You're not Ron...
    Donor
    Florida State Seminoles

    I just tried the 2021 Dovetail and it was fantastic. What a world we live in where fantastic bourbon just sits on the shelf (for $80.)
     
    Lipp and Leeroy Jenkins! like this.
  14. pratyk

    pratyk Arsenal FC, Rutgers Scarlet Knights
    Rutgers Scarlet KnightsArsenal

    What's a good $ for MND these days? I see a store has it for 129 and another for 139.
     
  15. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    $120ish has been retail in the past
     
    pratyk and BrickTamland like this.
  16. theregionsitter

    theregionsitter Well-Known Member
    TMB OG
    Notre Dame Fighting IrishChicago White SoxIndianapolis ColtsColumbus Blue JacketsColumbus Crew

    $129 is maybe a buy, $139 would be a pass from me

    I liked this last batch but that’s getting expensive
     
    pratyk likes this.
  17. BrickTamland

    BrickTamland You're not Ron...
    Donor
    Florida State Seminoles

    I’d buy for $129. Secondary seems to be $160?
     
    Lipp, Keef and pratyk like this.
  18. Leeroy Jenkins!

    Leeroy Jenkins! At least I have chicken
    Donor

    Lol shit stable. I'm calling my barrel pick that. Warehouse: "Shit Stable"
     
  19. Leeroy Jenkins!

    Leeroy Jenkins! At least I have chicken
    Donor

    Yeah its usually right next to the Armida and Seagrass.

    Row of Greatness
     
  20. pperc

    pperc Well-Known Member
    Donor

    This is a great summary of all of our thoughts on these
     
    sem, NYGator, Keef and 3 others like this.
  21. pperc

    pperc Well-Known Member
    Donor

    Midwinter nights dram? Retail is 99.99. Can be found for 89.99 in NJ sometimes.
     
  22. Keef

    Keef Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Georgia BulldogsAtlanta BravesAtlanta United

    AndersHolmvik, sem, ARCO and 5 others like this.
  23. Tangman

    Tangman Well-Known Member
    Donor
    North Carolina State WolfpackCharlotte HornetsWashington Football TeamEverton

    Believe this will actually be Barton juice based on the label
     
  24. pperc

    pperc Well-Known Member
    Donor

    barrel entry proof..
     
  25. Keef

    Keef Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Georgia BulldogsAtlanta BravesAtlanta United

    125 is still high for BT outside of the Stagg line
     
    pperc likes this.
  26. pperc

    pperc Well-Known Member
    Donor

    yes, I Know. just wanted to mention this
     
  27. gritzy

    gritzy I am a hurricane on the golf course

    wow they definitely sound young, makes me question whether I want an AE pick at all from anywhere
     
  28. gritzy

    gritzy I am a hurricane on the golf course

    wonder if its the same stuff going into the barton Kirkland stuff for Costco
     
  29. Tangman

    Tangman Well-Known Member
    Donor
    North Carolina State WolfpackCharlotte HornetsWashington Football TeamEverton

    pretty sure it is (just at higher proof). The TTB for that also listed Buffalo trace and then the same DSPs.

    Just a younger 1792 FP is my guess.
     
    gritzy and Keef like this.
  30. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    I wouldn’t buy one.
     
    gritzy and g8r like this.
  31. Leeroy Jenkins!

    Leeroy Jenkins! At least I have chicken
    Donor

    Hey if I can get it for 2 or 3 bucks I'm not complaining.
     
    Tangman, BrickTamland and g8r like this.
  32. jbr

    jbr Well-Known Member
    Donor TMB OG

    A96F9145-7E06-4B81-B65C-6190DBCA8573.jpeg
    Took a flyer on vacation for $45. I’m not a big KC fan, but this is pretty good. It’s a 6 year rye so I said wtheck.
     
    Keef, Degausser and RockHardJawn39 like this.
  33. gilstein21

    gilstein21 Tight Rip 26 Seal Right
    Washington State CougarsAuburn TigersSt. Louis CardinalsGreen Bay PackersWyoming Cowboys

    I do like their rye so that’s probably fantastic.
     
  34. BrickTamland

    BrickTamland You're not Ron...
    Donor
    Florida State Seminoles

    I got one for $30 and loved it at that price. At $45+ though, it's not Pikesville.

    And I'll be taking the recommendation from someone ITT and trying the Stellum rye next week. 115 proof for $55.
     
  35. jbr

    jbr Well-Known Member
    Donor TMB OG

    The abc store had KC rye for $30, but not store pick, barrel proof, etc.
     
  36. BrickTamland

    BrickTamland You're not Ron...
    Donor
    Florida State Seminoles

    Yeah, I've seen the store pick barrel proofs in the $45-50 range, but this one I got for a discount from a buddy that picked the barrel.
     
  37. NYGator

    NYGator Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Florida GatorsNew York YankeesNew York KnicksNew York GiantsNew York IslandersNew York City Football ClubTottenham HotspurUnited States Men's National Soccer Team

    The only thing missing from it was the word astringent. I feel it had to be used somewhere in some way.
     
  38. Frankie Carbone

    Frankie Carbone eh che se dice
    Florida State SeminolesNew York YankeesNew York KnicksTampa Bay BuccaneersOrlando CityLazio

    Is very old st nick summer rye any good?
     
  39. NYGator

    NYGator Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Florida GatorsNew York YankeesNew York KnicksNew York GiantsNew York IslandersNew York City Football ClubTottenham HotspurUnited States Men's National Soccer Team

    And with all of the AE tasting bad news, I just went back to the store so that he can be the next victim of these samples. It felt somewhat cathartic that I told him we had no interest in them and he absolutely understood.

    On the positive front, he is on the hunt. We should be getting Sazerac samples (BrickTamland ) next week and if we say go it may only take 8 weeks to get it done. He has a couple of more inquiries in the hopper. Four Roses is not a no, but it is not a right now, because they have nothing available. The rep did promise him he would be first in line once it opens up again.
     
    poor paul, Speirs, pratyk and 10 others like this.
  40. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    Team Knob Creek blows
    whats the price on it, I’m going to the price on it blows
     
  41. Frankie Carbone

    Frankie Carbone eh che se dice
    Florida State SeminolesNew York YankeesNew York KnicksTampa Bay BuccaneersOrlando CityLazio

    $180. I take it that it’s a hard pass
     
  42. Detlef Schrempf

    Detlef Schrempf Well-Known Member
    Donor

    So very old st Nick was originally a Julian Van Winkle bottling and then was done by Willet IIRC, neither have anything to do with it anymore it’s sourced, it’s over priced trying to charge based off the nostalgia or mis identification of it as one of the older bottles imo.
     
    gritzy and Frankie Carbone like this.
  43. Leeroy Jenkins!

    Leeroy Jenkins! At least I have chicken
    Donor

    Shelf Turd living off a name like Black Maple Hills
     
    Lipp, g8r, BrickTamland and 1 other person like this.
  44. sem

    sem Well-Known Member
    Donor

    Why would AE even offer up barrels like that for a pick?
     
    pperc likes this.
  45. pperc

    pperc Well-Known Member
    Donor

    it's the standard 2 crappy 1 OK offering so you take something since one is clearly the best. i think it's a common tactic, honestly. Unless you are a known group/picker and they know better.
     
    RockHardJawn39 and sem like this.
  46. Keef

    Keef Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Georgia BulldogsAtlanta BravesAtlanta United

    Baby Saz pick? That would be awesome
     
    RockHardJawn39, Lipp, ARCO and 5 others like this.
  47. sem

    sem Well-Known Member
    Donor

    Not going to be the one.

    In.
     
    construxboy, Lipp and Keef like this.
  48. theregionsitter

    theregionsitter Well-Known Member
    TMB OG
    Notre Dame Fighting IrishChicago White SoxIndianapolis ColtsColumbus Blue JacketsColumbus Crew

    Got my bar finally- missing some bottles that are still at my other house but feeling this. Gonna fill that beverage fridge up with Mexican lagers and rose
     

    Attached Files:

  49. NYGator

    NYGator Well-Known Member
    Donor
    Florida GatorsNew York YankeesNew York KnicksNew York GiantsNew York IslandersNew York City Football ClubTottenham HotspurUnited States Men's National Soccer Team

    To be honest it doesn't taste that different from their normal stuff, so that is pretty much their product. Beautiful bottle though.
     
    sem and DistantFactor like this.