I think Winston has the best and worst individual games at some point in the season while Mariota will be consistently average. Think the Bucs WR core eventually allows Winston to have more good games by the end of the year.
Winston and I dont think its very close. Think he will be a good QB plus he has a lot better weapons than Tennessee
Winston has much better weapons on the outside and a much better RB. Both have shit tier OL, but the playmakers like VJax and Evans will give Winston the better TD and pass yardage. Easier division too
Winston easily. He has 2 really good WRs and Doug Martin looks back to normal plus our RB's really really suck.
I mean if Winston is getting murdered like he did last night, I don't know how anyone could say he has any chance at having a "good" year
I actually think it may be Mariota because he will take less chances and play in a more tailor made, conservative offense (like RG3 as a rookie) than Winston will.
If Winston can get decent protection then him but if it's like last night I would take Mariotttttttta
If he stays healthy, Winston will have a better statistical season (despite being responsible for far more turnovers). Tennessee has a good LT but the rest of their OL is basically as bad as TB's. And Evans, Jackson, ASJ, Martin >>>> Wright, Hicks/Douglas, Walker, Sankey. (Mariota will be a better pro, though.)
Winston is surrounded by weapons. Mariotta........ Not so much. Plus he's still got to fully deprogram from that Oregon offense.
You should probably leave the 'rape someone very close to him' jokes to someone who didn't have Daniel Hood on their team.
That will easily be the biggest steal of the draft by the end of the year NFL.com did rate my draft as a C and say I would finish in last place
Winston will throw for more yards, more TDS and more INTs Mariota have higher comp%, rush yds and fewer turnovers. Both teams will win 6-7 games. I'm calling it a wash.